The Blogs: ‘Politically homeless’ is the new identity for American Jews | Andrew Silow-Carroll

The article explores the 'politically homeless' label adopted by some American Jews ahead of the 2026 midterms, citing estrangement from both parties due to antisemitism and anti-Israel rhetoric. Polls show Jewish voters still favor Democrats by wide margins, but many express unease, particularly in races featuring progressive candidates critical of Israel.

The article examines the growing use of the term 'politically homeless' among American Jews ahead of the 2026 midterms. It cites multiple Jewish voters and leaders who feel alienated from both the Republican Party and the Democratic Party, the latter due to rising antisemitism and anti-Israel rhetoric from progressive candidates. However, polling data from the Jewish Electorate Institute and the Jewish Voters Resource Center shows that Jewish voters still overwhelmingly support Democrats — 71% in one September survey. The piece profiles Jewish Democrats in Maine and Michigan who are torn between their party loyalty and discomfort with candidates like Abdul El-Sayed, whose comments on Israel have caused deep misgivings. Some, like Cantor Regina Hayut, have refrained from campaign activities. Political scientists and rabbis quoted suggest that while feelings of estrangement are real, most non-Orthodox Jews will likely continue voting Democratic, though some may stay home. The article notes that Orthodox Jews have shifted Republican, with 72% favoring the GOP in a generic ballot.