First publication: High Court rejects bereaved father's petition – with outrageous claim
The High Court of Justice summarily dismissed a petition filed by bereaved father Kobi Samerano, MK Yulia Malinovsky, and the B'Tselem organization to evacuate an UNRWA building in Kafr Aqab, citing lack of standing. The article points to alleged selective enforcement, noting that in the past the High Court has heard petitions from left-wing organizations even without direct victims.
The High Court of Justice summarily dismissed a petition filed by bereaved father Kobi Samerano, MK Yulia Malinovsky, and the B'Tselem organization to evacuate an UNRWA building in Kafr Aqab. The reason for the dismissal was lack of standing, arguing that the Jerusalem Municipality was the one that demanded enforcement of the UNRWA law and was not among the petitioners. The article points to alleged selective enforcement, noting that over the years the High Court has heard dozens of petitions from left-wing organizations without the main victims joining them, including petitions against the closure of the UNRWA compound, for the entry of the Red Cross into prisons, and for the entry of food into Gaza. B'Tselem stated that the High Court provides relief to terrorists while bypassing the procedure of standing, but rejected a petition aimed at protecting the security of Israeli citizens. The decision raises questions given the use of the standing argument for summary dismissal, while in the past this issue was fluid and dependent on the identity of the petitioner.
First publication: High Court rejects bereaved father's petition – with outrageous claim