Who will write history? The Muslim demand to change textbooks stirs the US | Mor Shapira
An opinion piece examining the Muslim struggle in the US to change textbooks, colliding between the desire to correct anti-Muslim stereotypes and demands for censorship, exemption from gender studies, and challenges to science and Holocaust education.
An opinion piece by Mor Shapira in Maariv examines the public struggle of Muslims in the United States to change textbooks in public schools, aiming to remove anti-Muslim stereotypes and present Islam's contributions to science and culture. The article describes how the Muslim community, after years of a defensive stance following the 9/11 attacks, has moved from a victim status and taken positions on local education boards, especially in Texas. However, the article points to a dilemma: the same liberal principles that protect the Muslim student require exposure to values of gender equality and LGBTQ+ rights, which conservative factions view as moral permissiveness. Muslim demands include exemptions from gender and sexuality classes, censorship of books, and challenges to science and Holocaust studies. The article quotes figures like Imam John Adrar, who called the American education system "corrupt," and Imam Tom Pashin, who called for establishing independent Islamic schools. On the other hand, liberal and Jewish organizations express concern about harm to other minority rights and antisemitism. The conclusion: the challenge is to find a golden path between correcting historical injustices and avoiding censorship and erosion of scientific truth.
Who will write history? The Muslim demand to change textbooks stirs the US | Mor Shapira