Where is the line? The race of students and universities in the age of AI
Artificial intelligence is changing the admissions process at US universities: students use ChatGPT to write essays, while academic institutions use AI to screen applicants. Based on a CNN report, the article presents the dilemma of identifying the personal voice in the technological age, and the lack of uniformity in university policies.
Artificial intelligence is transforming the US college admissions process, especially the writing of the admissions essay. Many high school students use AI tools like ChatGPT to draft and improve their essays, and sometimes let them write the essays entirely. At the same time, universities themselves are beginning to use AI to sort and evaluate applicants, creating a sense of unfairness among students. The article, based on a CNN report, quotes various sources: Kate Gilbertson, a Berkeley graduate, notes that many drafts lack natural characteristics of teenage writing; Ashley Pale, dean of admissions at Caltech, explains that the institution tries to distinguish between legitimate assistance and replacing the applicant's personal voice; and Sophie Sejani, an admissions consultant, argues that students have already grown up alongside the technology. Virginia Tech uses AI to handle 57,622 applications, while the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill has stepped back from using an automated tool to rank essays. Tulane University canceled a specific supplemental essay due to AI concerns. A survey by EAB found that 82% of respondents used ChatGPT in their search for institutions. The article reflects a broader dilemma: how to identify the applicant's personal voice in an age where a machine can polish it.
Where is the line? The race of students and universities in the age of AI