The legal precedent that endangers Israel: the historical implications of the ICJ's ruling on genocide
The International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya. The author analyzes the implications for Israel: lowering the threshold for proving genocide, a precedent for a lawsuit by a state not party to the conflict, and the connection to South Africa's case against Israel. He expresses cautious optimism due to the non-unanimous ruling and the long time until a decision in the Israeli case.
The International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled today that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya. The author argues that this ruling may have far-reaching implications for Israel, in three areas: First, this is the first time the Court has determined a state's direct responsibility for genocide, as opposed to previous rulings on non-compliance with a convention. Second, the ruling lowers the threshold for proving genocide, which the author says is not coincidental given the open case against Israel. Third, this is the first time the Court has so ruled in a lawsuit filed by a state not party to the conflict, similar to South Africa's case against Israel. The author expresses cautious optimism: the ruling was passed by a non-landslide majority, with a critical dissenting opinion, and there is time until a decision in the Israeli case (not before 2030). He calls on Israel to prepare in the diplomatic and public relations arenas.