The judge exploited power disparities - but no action will be taken against him

The Commissioner for Public Complaints Against Judges ruled that a judge took a complainant's phone during a hearing without permission. The judge expressed remorse, and the complaint was exhausted with a note given to him. The commissioner issued principled guidelines for judges regarding the inspection of digital devices.

The Commissioner for Public Complaints Against Judges, Asher Kola, ruled that a judge took a complainant's mobile phone during a hearing, without permission and exploiting power disparities in the courtroom. The complainant argued that the judge violated his privacy and showed hostility. The judge defended himself by stating that civil procedure regulations authorize him to order the presentation of any document, and that a mobile phone and contact list are considered a document. He further claimed he acted out of a duty to seek the truth. The commissioner determined that given the limited scope of the inspection, the judge's sincere remorse, and the lessons learned, there is no place for severe disciplinary measures, and the complaint was exhausted by giving a note. Additionally, the commissioner issued principled guidelines for judges regarding the inspection of litigants' digital devices.

The judge exploited power disparities - but no action will be taken against him