The Blogs: We're happy to host gap-year kids for shabbat; that doesn't make us a hotel | Chavi Eisenberg

Chavi Eisenberg recounts how a Facebook vent about a seminary student's request for five Shabbat guests went viral, sparking a debate about hospitality expectations. She reflects on the pressures on host families amid war and calls for mutual understanding, while continuing to host.

Chavi Eisenberg, a host of Shabbat guests in Israel, describes a personal experience that sparked a viral online debate. After receiving a WhatsApp request from a seminary student asking to bring four friends for Shabbat, she responded with a snarky comment and vented on Facebook. The post reached tens of thousands of people, drawing intense reactions. Some understood her frustration, others thought she was harsh, and some suggested she stop hosting altogether. Eisenberg reflects on the pressures on host families, especially amid war and military service, and calls for mutual understanding between hosts and parents of gap-year students. Despite the controversy, she continues to host, welcoming three guests for the upcoming Shabbat.

The Blogs: We're happy to host gap-year kids for shabbat; that doesn't make us a hotel | Chavi Eisenberg