The Blogs: My grandfather helped Reform Judaism reckon with Zionism. Now it's my turn | Naamah Kelman
Reform Rabbi Naamah Kelman reflects on her grandfather's 1937 vote that moved the Reform movement toward Zionism, and connects it to the current debate over ordaining anti-Zionist rabbis. She argues for engagement through the Year-In-Israel program.
Naamah Kelman, a Reform rabbi living in Jerusalem, reflects on her grandfather Rabbi Felix Levy's pivotal 1937 vote that steered the Reform movement toward supporting a Jewish homeland. She connects this history to the current debate within the Reform movement about whether to ordain anti-Zionist rabbis. Kelman argues that the Year-In-Israel program at Hebrew Union College is essential for exposing students to Israel's complexities and fostering engagement. She acknowledges concerns about Israel's conduct in Gaza and the West Bank but emphasizes the importance of dialogue and direct experience over exclusion. The piece is a personal and historical reflection on Zionism, Reform Judaism, and the future of Jewish peoplehood.