Renting a car abroad? Sixt demanded thousands of dollars for damages and canceled
Four customers who rented cars from Sixt at Milwaukee's airport were charged thousands of dollars for disputed damages and illegal fees. The charges were only canceled after a prolonged struggle or media inquiry. This comes against the backdrop of an $11 million settlement agreement from 2025.
Four customers who rented cars from Sixt at Milwaukee's airport in Wisconsin were charged thousands of dollars for disputed damages and fees prohibited by state law. One notable case is that of Christopher Nienhaus, who rented a car in October and was charged $1,589 for stains and scratches, including nearly $500 in illegal fees. The debt was sent to collections and only canceled after media intervention. Todd Lofgren was charged $6,265 for "graffiti," Brenda Bass was charged nearly $600 for a dent already documented in the contract, and Autumn Wojciechowski was required to pay $872 for a scratch. All four demands were canceled after customer struggles. Wisconsin law prohibits charging administrative, appraisal, loss-of-use, or diminished-value fees. In 2025, Sixt reached an $11 million settlement in a similar lawsuit.
Renting a car abroad? Sixt demanded thousands of dollars for damages and canceled