Rabbis challenge Antwerp court over investigation into illegal circumcisions
Two Antwerp rabbis, Rabbi Aharon Eckstein and Rabbi Moshe David Landau, appeared before the Antwerp Court of Appeal on Monday, challenging a judge's refusal to allow further investigation into their prosecution for performing Jewish ritual circumcisions. The case began 18 months ago with raids in the Jewish Quarter. The prosecution accuses the mohels of assault and unlawful practice of medicine.
Two Antwerp rabbis, Rabbi Aharon Eckstein and Rabbi Moshe David Landau, appeared before the Antwerp Court of Appeal on Monday, challenging a judge's refusal to allow further investigation into the legal and religious grounds for their prosecution for performing Jewish ritual circumcisions. The case began 18 months ago when Belgian authorities raided multiple sites, including two in Antwerp's Jewish Quarter, following a complaint from a member of the Jewish community named Moshe Friedman. The prosecution accuses the mohels of intentional, premeditated assault and battery of a minor and unlawful practice of medicine. The defense is challenging a July 15 decision by the investigating judge, Paul Van Santvliet, who refused three requests: for an independent expert on the Royal Decree of June 20, 1820, which authorizes mohels; for an expert to explain brit milah and its legal protections; and for clarification of the prosecution's list of 47 alleged victims, which contains repeated names. The Jewish community has expressed outrage, accusing the prosecutor's office of criminalizing circumcision and infringing on religious freedom.
Rabbis challenge Antwerp court over investigation into illegal circumcisions