Otzma Yehudit proposes Law of Return amendment threatening recognition of Diaspora conversions
Otzma Yehudit submitted a bill to amend the Law of Return, seeking to restrict conversion recognition to those performed 'according to halacha' and overturn a High Court ruling recognizing Reform and Conservative conversions for aliyah. The bill, submitted by MK Limor Son Har-Melech, does not define 'halacha,' raising questions about its impact on private Orthodox conversions and Diaspora Jewry.
Otzma Yehudit submitted a bill to amend Israel's Law of Return, two days after the 26th Knesset was sworn in, seeking to restrict recognition of conversions to those performed 'according to halacha' and effectively overturn a landmark High Court ruling that recognized Reform and Conservative conversions for immigration and registration purposes. The bill, submitted by MK Limor Son Har-Melech, adds a clause defining a Jew as someone born to a Jewish mother who is not a member of another religion, or someone who converted 'according to halacha.' The stated aim is to render meaningless the High Court's 2021 Dahan ruling, which recognized non-Orthodox conversions performed in Israel. The bill does not define 'halacha,' leaving ambiguity about whether it refers to the Chief Rabbinate's standards or other Orthodox interpretations, potentially affecting private Orthodox conversions like Giyur K'Halacha. The proposal also applies to conversions abroad, threatening recognition of Reform and Conservative conversions performed overseas, which have been recognized since the 1980s. The Israel Democracy Institute notes this could affect Diaspora Jewry, where only 9% of US Jewish adults identify as Orthodox. The bill does not repeal the grandchild clause, so those with a Jewish grandparent could still immigrate as family members but not be registered as Jewish. Supporters argue the legislation addresses a long-avoided issue and ensures unity in Jewish law, while critics warn of a deep rift with world Jewry. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked a similar proposal in the 25th Knesset over Diaspora concerns.
Otzma Yehudit proposes Law of Return amendment threatening recognition of Diaspora conversions