Obesity Misdiagnosis: How to Know if BMI Is Misleading You

A new study in Nature states that relying solely on BMI leads to misdiagnosis of obesity in millions of people. The study proposes a new diagnostic framework that distinguishes between clinical obesity (with organ damage) and pre-clinical obesity, enabling more precise treatment.

A large-scale new study published in the journal Nature concludes that using only BMI leads to misdiagnosis of millions of people with obesity. According to the study, up to 8.6% of people are not diagnosed as obese, while up to 3.1% are incorrectly classified as such. The new diagnostic framework, proposed for use from 2025, distinguishes for the first time between 'clinical obesity' – a condition where excess fat causes damage to internal organs – and 'pre-clinical obesity' – excess weight that has not yet harmed bodily functions. About one-third of obesity cases are actually clinical obesity, an active disease requiring specific treatment. The new approach includes measurements such as waist circumference, waist-to-height ratio, and body fat scans, and also examines signs of organ damage or physical limitations. The study showed that clinical obesity is associated with a 69% higher risk of mortality over a follow-up period of more than a decade, compared to only a 19% higher risk among those with pre-clinical obesity. The goal is to tailor more precise treatment, including weight-loss medications, to people who truly need them.

Obesity Misdiagnosis: How to Know if BMI Is Misleading You