Leah Enbal Dor: "The Judging Network" – Between a Democratic Breakthrough and a Danger to the Rule of Law

Leah Enbal Dor reviews Dr. Anat Peleg's book "The Judging Network," which examines the phenomenon of online discussions on social networks where citizens investigate cases and pass judgment outside the legal system. Peleg presents the phenomenon as having democratic potential alongside dangers of spreading false information and incitement, while analyzing Israeli cases such as the acquittal of Roman Zadorov and the Me Too movement.

Leah Enbal Dor reviews Dr. Anat Peleg's new book, "The Judging Network," which examines the phenomenon of online discussions on social networks where citizens investigate cases, interpret evidence, and pass judgment – sometimes outside the legal system. Peleg presents the phenomenon as having two faces: on one hand, a danger of spreading false information, shaming, and incitement; on the other hand, a democratic power to expose failures in the legal system, empower marginalized voices, and shape social norms, such as the Me Too movement. The reviewer emphasizes that the book is based on research and interviews with crime victims, prosecutors, and judges, and analyzes major Israeli cases such as the acquittal of Roman Zadorov and the struggle against Eyal Golan. The article notes that Peleg sees the judging network as an alternative legal arena, but warns against populism and consciousness engineering that threaten democracy.

Leah Enbal Dor: "The Judging Network" – Between a Democratic Breakthrough and a Danger to the Rule of Law