Israel's problem is not the government. The problem is the system | Col. (res.) Amir Noy

Col. (res.) Amir Noy argues that Israel's political problem is not the current government but the system of governance. He proposes a framework for change that includes direct election of the prime minister, regional representation in the Knesset, separation of powers, and appointment of professional ministers from outside the Knesset.

In an opinion piece published in Ma'ariv, Col. (res.) Amir Noy argues that Israel's political problem is not rooted in any particular government, but in the system of governance itself. According to him, the Israeli system is based on nationwide proportional representation, where citizens vote for a party but do not directly elect their representatives, and the government is formed through coalition negotiations that sometimes grant significant power to small parties. Noy presents a working paper titled "Redesigning the System of Government in Israel," which includes five principles: direct election of the prime minister in two rounds, a five-year term limited to two terms; a 120-member Knesset, with 84 elected in regional districts and 36 nationwide, using the STV method; genuine separation of powers with an independent constitutional court; appointment of ministers from outside the Knesset based on professional experience, subject to public hearings; and opening the system to candidates who are not party members. The article emphasizes that this is a structural discussion unrelated to right or left, and calls for a broad public debate on the future of democracy in Israel.