Israel or Netanyahu: Who is Shin Bet chief David Zini loyal to? - opinion
Columnist Yaakov Katz questions whether Shin Bet chief David Zini is loyal to Israel or to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, citing Zini's role in election-day police raids on Arab activists, his comparison of alleged voter fraud to October 7, and his meeting with Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot. Katz argues the conduct raises serious questions about institutional independence.
Columnist Yaakov Katz questions whether Shin Bet chief David Zini is loyal to the state of Israel or to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, following a series of events surrounding the October 27 election. Katz describes how police raided the homes of Arab activists associated with Ra'am on election day, based on a tip that passed through Netanyahu's chief of staff. One activist, Dr. Saef Abu Reash, was held for six days before a court ordered his release and criticized the investigation. Netanyahu seized on the allegations of vote-buying and foreign interference from Qatar, though no large-scale evidence emerged. Katz reports that Zini called the alleged voter fraud the Shin Bet's 'October 7,' a comparison Katz finds extraordinary given the agency's failure to prevent the 2023 Hamas attack. Zini also told Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot that previous Shin Bet directors had been afraid to investigate Arab election fraud and that he decided to 'turn over this stone.' Katz argues that Zini's conduct raises serious questions about the independence of Israel's institutions and notes the contrast with the Shin Bet's apparent inaction against Jewish extremist violence in the West Bank.
Israel or Netanyahu: Who is Shin Bet chief David Zini loyal to? - opinion