Investigations drag on for years, trials last more than a decade | The foot-dragging in the justice system

Nettael Bandel's report on ynet exposes the chronic delays in Israel's criminal justice system, from investigations that last years to trials that drag on for over a decade. The article presents cases such as that of former Hadera mayor Zvika Gendelman, whose nine-year criminal proceeding ended in community service without a conviction, and Petah Tikva mayor Rami Greenberg, who was investigated in 2022 and is still awaiting a decision. According to prosecution data, about 30% of cases exceed guideline timelines.

Nettael Bandel's report on ynet describes the ongoing foot-dragging in Israel's criminal justice system, from the investigation stage to the verdict. The article opens with the case of former Hadera mayor Zvika Gendelman, whose criminal proceeding lasted nearly nine years and ended in community service without a conviction. Gendelman was quoted in a post he published: "For nine years I paid, together with my family, a heavy personal price." The article notes that Petah Tikva mayor Rami Greenberg was first investigated in July 2022 and has only now been summoned for a hearing, with a final decision expected at least another year away. Also mentioned is state witness Shlomo Filber, who finished his testimony in mid-2022 and still awaits a decision. According to prosecution data, the rate of cases exceeding guideline timelines stands at about 30% in 2024 for serious criminal cases. The article brings a discussion among former district court judges at a conference of the Israeli Forum for Law and Liberty: Judge Ron Shapira said the existing solutions are "a band-aid on the big problem," Judge Menachem Raniel argued that "there is no problem of overload, there is a problem of management," and Judge Moshe Drori denied the overload discourse. The article notes a similar disagreement among Supreme Court justices, with President Yitzhak Amit arguing that the proliferation of defendants' rights discourse lengthens proceedings, while Justices Barak-Erez and Elron emphasize that defendants' rights are a cornerstone.

Investigations drag on for years, trials last more than a decade | The foot-dragging in the justice system