Israeli Supreme Court orders retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman convicted of rape

Deputy Chief Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, convicted of rape by deception, citing a procedural error in the appeal process where the court convicted him without noting the prosecution's withdrawal of sex crime charges.

Deputy Chief Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of rape by deception after being unanimously acquitted in the district court. The decision was made following an error in the appeal process: during the hearing in September 2024, the prosecution announced it was withdrawing its request to convict Shtetman of sex offenses and sought only a conviction for assault, but in March 2025, the Supreme Court justices unanimously convicted Shtetman of rape by deception, without noting the state's withdrawal. Sohlberg ruled that the verdict was based on a misunderstanding of the state's position, raising concerns of a miscarriage of justice. Justice Yechiel Kasher, who was part of the original panel, clarified that had he known the prosecution had unconditionally withdrawn, he would not have joined the conviction. The retrial will take place in the Supreme Court before an expanded panel of five judges.

Israeli Supreme Court orders retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman convicted of rape