Exposure: Senior Shin Bet official's warning about harm to state security - and the anger within the organization

ynet has learned of an unusual conflict within the Shin Bet: the head of the legal advisory division circulated a legal opinion warning that the increasing use of security justifications at the expense of human rights could harm state security. In response, an operational figure circulated a document against the legal advisory. Shin Bet chief David Zini was updated on the details.

ynet has learned of an unusual conflict within the Shin Bet, which began several months after October 7, during the tenure of former Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar. The head of the organization's legal advisory division circulated a legal opinion warning that the increasing use of security justifications at the expense of human rights is narrowing the legal maneuvering space, and that High Court justices are expressing growing criticism of this. According to him, the very discussion of these issues in the High Court could be used against Israel internationally and harm state security. In response, an operational figure in the Shin Bet circulated his own document accusing the legal advisory of restricting service work, attaching the legal opinion as evidence. The current Shin Bet chief, David Zini, was updated on the details of the dispute upon taking office in October 2025, and this is among the reasons for the tension between him and the Shin Bet's legal counsel. The details reached senior officials in the Justice Ministry and diplomatic sources.

Exposure: Senior Shin Bet official's warning about harm to state security - and the anger within the organization