"Double evil": what Ben-Gurion really thought about draft evasion

Archival letters from Ben-Gurion reveal how he reconsidered his decision to grant deferments to yeshiva students. In 1954, he feared that exemption from service was leading to mass evasion, calling it a "double evil." The article quotes ultra-Orthodox lawmakers who cited the original 1948 decision, and contrasts them with later letters in which Ben-Gurion proposed compromises and expressed concern.

The article examines the evolution of David Ben-Gurion's views on exempting yeshiva students from service in the IDF, drawing on archival letters from 1948-1963. At the center is the contrast between current references by ultra-Orthodox politicians to Ben-Gurion's original decision and his later concerns. MKs Ben-Tzur (Shas) and Porush (United Torah Judaism) cited the 1948 decision to defer 400 students during a Knesset session on November 16, 2026. However, the letters show that by 1954 Ben-Gurion was worried about the artificial increase in the number of students to evade the draft, calling it a "double evil" — undermining security and desecrating God's name. In 1958 he proposed three months of basic training for yeshiva students, and in 1963 he acknowledged his share of responsibility to his successor Levi Eshkol.

"Double evil": what Ben-Gurion really thought about draft evasion