Does a WhatsApp message constitute a binding contract? So ruled the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court overturned a district court decision and canceled the transfer of a penthouse apartment from a former partner, ruling that a WhatsApp message did not demonstrate sufficient intent to form a binding commitment. The Court determined it was a promise to give a gift, and that the man had lawfully retracted it.
The Supreme Court overturned a district court decision and canceled the transfer of a penthouse apartment from a former partner, ruling that a WhatsApp message did not demonstrate sufficient intent to form a binding commitment. The couple had been in a relationship for about two decades and have two children. After they separated, the woman sued for half the rights in the properties under the presumption of joint ownership, while the man argued for separation of assets. The district court ruled that a text message in which the man wrote "I want to tell you for a long time that the penthouse apartment will be registered in your name when it's finished" constituted a binding commitment. The Supreme Court ruled that this was a promise to give a gift, and that one can retract it as long as the recipient has not changed their position in reliance. It further held that the message did not express the required level of intent for a gift transaction, and that the ambiguity in material details made the commitment insufficiently certain. The decision reflects a broader trend of stricter formal requirements in contracts.
Does a WhatsApp message constitute a binding contract? So ruled the Supreme Court