Departure Tax as a Parable

Shaul Amsterdamski analyzes the Tax Authority's proposal for a departure tax, which sparked a storm online. He explains that the tax is relatively small, but the public's reaction stems from the principle: the public feels the state is looking for more tax sources instead of addressing structural issues like Haredi participation in the workforce and the IDF. The author calls for comprehensive tax reform.

Shaul Amsterdamski, a journalist for Kan News, writes in his column in Calcalist about the Tax Authority's proposal to impose a new tax on departing flights. The proposal, published in October by Dr. Uri Grufel and Nili Ben Tovim, sparked an online uproar after Ben Tovim responded to criticism. Amsterdamski explains that the tax is relatively small: 12 shekels for a flight to Eilat, 60 shekels to Europe, and 275 shekels to distant destinations. However, he argues that the public reaction stems from the principle: the public feels the state is looking for more tax sources instead of addressing structural issues. The article analyzes Israel's tax system, where the top two deciles bear more than 90% of income tax, while large populations do not participate in the labor market. Amsterdamski notes that the gap between what taxpayers pay and what they receive in return is enormous, and the transfer is mainly between non-Haredi Jewish households. He calls for comprehensive tax reform but emphasizes that rehabilitation must begin with education, the labor market, and the security burden. The author notes that in the coming years, tax increases are expected due to war costs, but the technological revolution at the Tax Authority may increase revenues.

Departure Tax as a Parable