Assaf Moghadam maps the terror threat but misses the child inside it - opinion

Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin critiques Assaf Moghadam's counterterrorism analysis for missing the developmental psychology of the individual terrorist. She argues that early childhood, particularly in shame-honor cultures, shapes a mind predisposed to violence, and that ideology is a psychological prosthesis. She calls for integrating clinicians into counterterrorism strategy and for early childhood interventions in Gaza.

Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, a psychoanalyst and counterterrorism scholar, critiques Assaf Moghadam's recent interviews with The Jerusalem Post, arguing that his analysis of the terror threat misses the developmental psychology of the individual terrorist. Moghadam, the new director of Reichman University's International Institute for Counter-Terrorism, maps four erosions of boundaries (young and old, one ideology and many, terror and conventional war, local and international conflict). Kobrin contends that these boundaries sit outside the person and fail to ask what happens inside a human being before he picks up a weapon. She argues that a 12-year-old recruit was formed long before any algorithm found him, and that the decisive years are the first three, in the relationship between infant and mother, and in the household's rules for shame, honor, and rage. She asserts that ideology is a psychological prosthesis for a capacity that never developed in the mind, and that the Jew is the oldest container for the contaminated. Kobrin calls for adding clinicians and developmental psychoanalysts to the counterterrorism table, and for interventions focused on early childhood in Gaza, such as trained caregivers, secure attachment, and nurseries where anger can be spoken instead of enacted. The framing relies on psychoanalytic vocabulary without procedural sourcing for claims about Gazan child-rearing practices.

Assaf Moghadam maps the terror threat but misses the child inside it - opinion