‘An evidentiary collapse’: How October 7 forced a rethink of sexual violence investigations

Prof. Yifat Bitton, a sexual violence legal expert, describes how the October 7 Hamas attacks forced a rethinking of evidence collection for sexual crimes. She details the evidentiary collapse: forensic teams were not deployed for weeks, biological evidence degraded, and protocols hindered collection. Her work led to a UNODC toolkit for first responders.

Prof. Yifat Bitton, a veteran sexual violence legal expert and president of Achva Academic College, recounts how the October 7 Hamas attacks compelled a fundamental rethinking of how to investigate and prosecute sexual violence in terrorist contexts. Bitton, who heads the RAIA Project documenting such crimes, explains that dedicated forensic teams were never deployed to the Gaza border communities in the immediate aftermath, as the area remained an active combat zone. By the time major crimes units arrived six weeks to two months later, most biological evidence had degraded. She describes a case where a forensic investigator noticed signs of sexual assault on a woman's body but did not collect a sample because only six forensic pathologists were available and the material could have come from a consensual partner. Bitton's 2024 report presented to the UN inspired the Foreign Ministry to develop a first-of-its-kind toolkit with the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, set for release soon, to guide first responders in preserving evidence at terrorist attack sites. She also addresses the international denial wave, noting the silence of UN Women and the misconceptions during Pramila Patten's visit, where the team expected to find ample evidence in a strong state like Israel.

‘An evidentiary collapse’: How October 7 forced a rethink of sexual violence investigations